If you read The Inside the ‘Zona 2015-16 Offseason Plan, you probably noticed that we advocated for signing a couple of short-term, mid-level starting pitchers. No one in their right mind thought that Zack Greinke was an option but apparently he was after the appropriate amount of deliberation. Shelby Miller was always sort of on the radar but then again, trade prices were reportedly so high that any kind of a deal seemed like a risky proposition. Then it all happened. The D-backs basically made two very unpredictable moves to fill their biggest void and it’s not like anyone’s complaining.
The Dodgers, meanwhile, did exactly what we thought the Diamondbacks would do. They went ahead and signed veteran lefty Scott Kazmir to a 3-year, $48 million deal that includes an opt-out after the first season and defers money over six seasons total. If Kazmir’s left arm falls off or he pitches poorly, he’ll get at least $48 million. If he does quite well, he could hit the market again after the 2016 season. We had suggested a 2-year, $32 million deal with a $16 million option for 2018 or a $2 million buyout. The AAV is the same but we kept the deal shorter while the Dodgers gave him a longer guarantee, but deferred a lot of the money and included the option. Overall, the Dodgers gave him more, if only by a small margin.
And while the Dodgers were reading our Offseason Plan because, hey, winter break in LA is boring, they went ahead and signed Japanese righty Kenta Maeda, too. The particulars here are still pretty murky, but we know this: Maeda decided to sign with the Dodgers who offered him an 8-year, $25 million deal that’s allegedly loaded with incentives. It probably has an opt-out or five in it – opt-outs are so hip these days. His AAV is $3.25 million per season, but there are believed to be $10-$12 million worth of performance bonuses annually. Maeda is clearly betting on himself here and the Dodgers were very inventive with the deal. We suggested a 4-year, $64 million contract, making for a $16 million AAV. If he hits his bonuses as it has been reported so far, he should make about $15 million per season. Opt-outs could significantly sway the deal, but those haven’t be reported yet. Our offer was definitely in the ballpark, but honestly, no one saw a deal like this coming for Maeda and we don’t have all the details yet, so I’ll withhold judgement on our offer.
Of course, it really matters that the Dodgers are adding these two, Kazmir and Maeda, to a collection of Clayton Kershaw, Brett Anderson, Hyun-jin Ryu, Alex Wood and eventually Brandon McCarthy. These two signings can slot comfortably in the middle of the rotation for Los Angeles whereas there certainly would have been more pressure in putting them behind Patrick Corbin and in front of Robbie Ray and either Chase Anderson or Rubby De La Rosa. It makes the Dodgers’ rotation better because it provides them with a ton of depth. Even though Anderson and Ryu have had a damned hard time staying healthy, the Dodgers will be less likely now to have to turn to Mike Bolsinger and Carlos Frias for starts. They have more starters than slots for them, but that’s not really a big problem because pitchers break and now they have a cupboard full of options.
It is somewhat interesting, however, that Los Angeles made the bulk, value play while Arizona spent big. That’s partly because Arizona had the biggest deficit to overcome, and they largely still do. The Dodgers, after missing out on Greinke and the like, decided to make a short commitment to Kazmir and somewhat unknown but at least relatively inexpensive commitment to Maeda. These are the types of deals that would have fit Arizona quite well given that The Contention Window almost surely won’t be any longer than three years (and might end up only being two) and the deals are clearly affordable for a team like the D-backs. That’s why we forecast them in the first place. Would it have been enough to make them #legit? Maybe not as much as Greinke and Miller do, but the penalties associated are a lot smaller and could have possibly allowed the team to diversify their acquisitions this winter. That does hold value.
About two weeks ago, I compared the D-backs’ rotation to that of the Dodgers and Giants and Padres and Rockies. While San Diego still has a pretty good rotation, they aren’t in the contender discussion for the division at this way-too-early juncture, so let’s just focus on the Giants and Dodgers. The signings of Kazmir and Maeda push the Dodgers further out front. Yes, there’s a duplication of efforts here as there are only so many rotation spots, but Los Angeles will almost surely never be forced to give a single start to a replacement level pitcher in 2016. That’s good for them and bad for the rest of the division. Nothing has changed for San Francisco, but it’s now clearly the Dodgers and everybody else. Kazmir and Maeda might not be superstars, but the collection of good-if-not-great pitchers in LA is enviable.
What I can’t overemphasize here is that Arizona paid huge sums in money, prospects and MLB player seasons for two guys who are projected to be about a win and half, maybe two wins better than what the Dodgers brought aboard. Those two wins could have been found elsewhere, perhaps in an actually serviceable catching partner for Welington Castillo and some bullpen upgrades. That’s not to say that what Arizona did was wrong, but they will still be paying $34 million for Zack Greinke six years from now while also being on the hook for all of Shelby Miller’s expensive seasons of team control through 2018. The back end of the Greinke deal will eat up all of Miller’s surplus value and then some. What the Diamondbacks did was risky and they did it to capitalize on a special time and place. That’s just fine so long as it works out (or at least nearly works out). The Dodgers, on the other hand, gave themselves more flexibility and spent less on shorter-term options (provided there’s an opt-out for Maeda in there somewhere).
The Diamondbacks went big and made the splash while the Dodgers played it smart. Having Clayton Kershaw to anchor your rotation helps, but let’s not act like Arizona didn’t have other options. They’ve called their shot, now it’s time to prove it was the right call.
Powered by: Web Designers
- Best part of Peralta’s 108 mph fliner over the fence, IMHO: that he got that much leverage despite scooping it out… https://t.co/ivBrl76adF, Apr 08
- RT @OutfieldGrass24: If you're bored of watching Patrick Corbin get dudes out, you can check out my latest for @TheAthleticAZ. https://t.co/k1DymgY7zO, Apr 04
- Of course, they may have overtaken the league lead for outs on the bases just now, also... But in 2017, Arizona ha… https://t.co/38MBrr2D4b, Apr 04
- Prior to the games today, there had only been 5 steals of 3rd this season (and no CS) in the National League. The… https://t.co/gVVL84vPQ5, Apr 04
- RT @OutfieldGrass24: Patrick Corbin has a WPA of .318 and it's only the fifth inning., Apr 04
Powered by: Web Designers
- Tarik Cohen is so fast he just tackled himself, 2 hours ago
- RT @JCGonzalezOR: Special thanks to @HillsboroHops for hosting a LatinX community outreach and visioning session. This organization i… https://t.co/OxmEgwOpEh, Dec 08
- Old friend alert https://t.co/xwSHU0F8Hn, Dec 08
- Every once in a while you get a beer that's just a little off... Usually happens to me at airports., Dec 07
- If Pollock doesn’t sign with a team that wears red uniforms I’m going to be really disappointed. Working theory: Se… https://t.co/zHn9DqzEiD, Dec 07